NCLB Reading First program under fed investigation, conflicts of interest FUBAR

On 2/23/07, I wrote this post, “US Dept. of Ed breaches prohibition on interfering w/state, local officials re: curriculum; spending billions improperly.”

Thank you to Progress Ohio for posting this entry today which links to this WaPo article, “Key Initiative of No Child Left Behind Under Federal Investigation.”

My February post provides plenty of answers as to why the Reading First program is under investigation, but this part alone angers me:

The Education Department’s inspector general, John P. Higgins Jr., said he has made several referrals to the Justice Department about the five-year-old program, which provides grants to improve reading for children in kindergarten through third grade.

Higgins declined to offer more specifics, but Christopher J. Doherty, former director of Reading First, said in an interview that he was questioned by Justice officials in November. The civil division of the U.S. attorney’s office for the District, which can bring criminal charges, is reviewing the matter.

Doherty, one of the two Education Department employees who oversaw the initiative, acknowledged yesterday that his wife had worked for a decade as a paid consultant for a reading program, Direct Instruction, that investigators said he improperly tried to force schools to use. He repeatedly failed to disclose the conflict on financial disclosure forms.

“I’m very proud of this program and my role in this program,” Doherty said in the interview. “I think it’s been implemented in accordance with the law.”

The Ed. Dept.’s inspector general report outlines incident after incident of where people with school districts detail the Doherty’s efforts to get them to use his wife’s program.

Even a major supporter of President Bush sees serious problems:

Another researcher, Sharon Vaughn, worked with Kame’enui, Simmons and Good to design Voyager Universal Literacy, a program that Reading First officials urged states to use. Vaughn was director of a center at the University of Texas that was hired to provide states advice on selecting Reading First tests and books.

The publisher of that product, Voyager Expanded Learning, was founded and run by Randy Best, a major Bush campaign contributor, who sold the company in 2005 for more than $350 million. Now Best runs Higher Ed Holdings, a company that develops colleges of education, where former education secretary Roderick R. Paige is a senior adviser and G. Reid Lyon, Bush’s former reading adviser, is an executive vice president.

“I’m very disappointed and saddened by the information that was provided at the hearing today,” said Lyon, who had been a strong defender of Reading First, which he said had nothing to do with his new job. “The issues appear much more serious than I had been led to understand.”

And last but not least, here’s how we know our founding fathers would be crying over the broken checks and balances system they devised because of essentially one party rule for so long:

Education Secretary Margaret Spellings, who declined to comment yesterday, has said management problems with Reading First “reflect individual mistakes.” But Doherty said nearly every aspect of the program was carefully monitored by the department and the White House, where Spelling was Bush’s top education adviser.

“This program was always firmly under the watch and control of the highest levels of the government,” Doherty said.

Helloooooww?

P.S.: expect ends justify the means explanations because, according to the WaPo piece:

Despite the controversy surrounding Reading First’s management, the percentage of students in the program who are proficient on fluency tests has risen about 15 percent, Education Department officials said. School districts across the country praise the program.

3 thoughts on “NCLB Reading First program under fed investigation, conflicts of interest FUBAR

  1. Currently use the Odyssey program (at a cost of $250,000 for a campus of 300 students in Taft, TX). Part of the funds pay for a Reading Coach who is forbidden to work with students according to the program guidelines. Our “Coach” is a certified teacher who spends her time sending cheery e-mails to build morale and plans after school teacher get-togethers. She assigned our three para-professionals (none of whom have teacher training) to work with our struggling readers.Stats on scores that rise 15% on fluency are skewed as several different people administer the tests, often the students practice the selections before the “real” score is entered into the computer program.Additionally, students who continue to struggle with phonics/fluency in third grade repeat the levels using the SAME materials in fourth grade. If students do not reach desired results at the end of fourth grade, they repeat the steps USING THE SAME MATERIALS they used in both third and fourth grade. This GENUINELY alters the validity of fluency results. You’d think there would be more than a 15% increase using a quarter of a million dollar program that the students have used for three years straight!

  2. And last but not least, here’s how we know our founding fathers would be crying over the broken checks and balances system they devised because of essentially one party rule for so longBlaming this on one-party rule “for so long” doesn’t make a lot of sense. First, the “so long” is six years, which isn’t exactly lengthy in US politics. (If you want “so long,” look at the forty years the Democrats controlled the House.) Second, according to the article, it appears that the Republican Justice Department has been questioning people since at least November–before the Democrats took control of Congress.

  3. Scariest piece of information from the article:”…Randy Best, a major Bush campaign contributor, who sold the company in 2005 for more than $350 million. Now Best runs Higher Ed Holdings, a company that develops colleges of education, where former education secretary Roderick R. Paige is a senior adviser and G. Reid Lyon, Bush’s former reading adviser, is an executive vice president.”Colleges of education founded by this lot of scallywags? It’s not about no children left behind — it is about dumbing down the population so that they can be lead dodo-like toward their own extinction.

Comment here

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s