World Evangelical Alliance wants end to dialogue, increase in conversion of Jews

From YNet News:

A formal decree drafted by the World Evangelical Alliance’s (WEA) Theology Commission during a Berlin conference held in August, has world Jewish communities up in arms: The decree, which explores “Jesus’ individuality and Jewish evangelism,” is meant, according to the WEA, to find ways in which Christians can profess their true love for the Jewish people, especially those residing in Europe.

The conference, which was attended by German Christians and Messianic Jews, ended with a statement calling for forfeiting the Christian-Jewish dialogue in favor of distributing the gospel among the Jewish people. This act, said the WEA, “should be made with a true concerns for the Jewish people’s redemption.”

The document that contains the directive is called, “The Berlin Declaration on the Uniqueness of Christ and Jewish Evangelism in the World Today” and you can read it here (pdf) (but you can see the full thing in this post, by an American who attended the Berlin conference, at  The writer of this Daily Kos post does a good job of outlining why then it is so unsettling to learn about the current GOP VP candidate’s history of religious affiliations.  And if you google blog search the name of the document, you will find some very frightening results which I don’t want to link to because frankly, I don’t want them coming to this blog.

The Anti-Defamation League (ADL) has issued this statement:

Promoting a campaign to convert Jews away from their faith is a serious affront to the Jewish people and disrespectful to Judaism’s own teachings.  Though the World Evangelical Alliance claims it seeks to convert Jews out of their “love” for Jews, we believe that if the WEA really loved Jews, they would respect Jewish teachings and recognize the integrity of Jewish tradition.

It is especially troubling that the WEA includes and validates the deceptive proselytizing tactics of Messianic Jews and groups like Jews for Jesus. To issue this declaration from Berlin, where the Nazis directed their Final Solution to exterminate the Jewish people, is the height of insensitivity. This Evangelical document is not an offer of love, but a prescription for hate. As long as the WEA teaches that Judaism is incomplete or misguided, anti-Semitism will continue.

We urge on the WEA to withdraw its call to target the Jews of Europe for conversion and immediately begin serious dialogue with Jewish interfaith representatives, so they can understand the immense pain and anger they are causing with their ill-advised and theologically misguided position.

Rabbi Brad Hirschfeld seems to think that dialogue is the answer, even though the statement clearly doesn’t embrace dialogue as much as evangelism, and admonishes the ADL and the Christians:

There are however two fundamental questions which the WEA must confront. First, is it possible that as much as they need to witness their understanding of the truth, they need to separate that public witness from the stated outcome of seeing me and my brothers and sisters join them in faith? In other words, I am calling upon the ADL, and all those who share their views, to reconsider the notion that Christian evangelism may be an act of love from their perspective. But I also ask if evangelical Christians are willing to consider that it may not be an act of love, if those on the receiving end do not experience it as such?

The second question is simple: can anyone out there point to a single time in human history which ended well, when the success of one group was defined by their ability to convert their neighbors? There isn’t one. You may not think I am right, but the damage done by those who wanted to “repair” the spiritual shortcomings of their neighbors, and judged that repair as necessary to attain blessing or salvation, is too vast to detail here.

So why not try something new for most of us? Genuine inter-faith dialogue in which each group tried to understand the logic and the love which motivates the other side. We are not likely to agree many things, I know. And it will be hard to give up the sense of moral superiority that we all love so much. But it strikes me as far healthier than Jews who intimate that Evangelicals are in cahoots with Nazis, and Christians who refuse to admit the damage done by well-intentioned people who just never got over seeing their neighbors as spiritually damaged goods.

The WEA declaration is pretty clear on not wanting more dialogue so I’m not quite sure why the rabbi is making this suggestion.  On this one, I lean in the ADL’s direction, especially having just spent several hours at Yad Vashem which offers proof after painful proof of all the influences that contributed to the Holocaust, and I struggle to imagine how Jews can feel comfortable supporting the McCain/Palin ticket, knowing the VP candidate’s religious leanings and its influence over her political efforts.

10 thoughts on “World Evangelical Alliance wants end to dialogue, increase in conversion of Jews

  1. Pingback: | angie newsome

  2. Matt, at the point you accept Jesus you stop being a Jew and are then called a Christian.

    I realize you think this gives you credibility by still calling yourself a Jew but the line is very clear. As a Jew I understand your difficulty in letting go of this honorable identifier.

    But It’s OK to refer to yourself as a Christian, calling yourself a Jew just isn’t the truth. If you are a Christian be proud of it.

  3. Jill,
    Yes, I do work with Jews for Jesus. I have been a believer in Jesus since 1978. You can read a little more about how that happened here:
    I think the point I made is clear. You quote YNET saying that the WEA statement calls for “forfeiting the Christian-Jewish dialogue.” As my quote from the WEA statement shows, it does no such thing. It states, among other things, that “dialogue and evangelism are not mutually exclusive.”

  4. Matt – thanks for reading and commenting. My brother was a Jew for Jesus for a few years in the 1980s and since that’s where your hyperlink goes I assume you are involved?

    Maybe you should say more about your experience.

    Yes I did read the document but that’s a fair question. I believe the intent I’ve inferred from the doc and the articles is accurate – you are saying it isn’t – based on what?

  5. I am a Jewish believer in Jesus. You need to get your facts straight before writing your articles. You quoted YNET’s statement: “The conference . . . ended with a statement calling for forfeiting the Christian-Jewish dialogue in favor of distributing the gospel among the Jewish people.” Do you just believe YNET? You give your readers a link to the WEA document, but did you read it for yourself? Here is what it actually says regarding Jewish-Christian dialogue: “Christians have much to learn from the Jewish people. We recognise our need to hear Jewish concerns. We affirm the importance of dialogue in promoting mutual understanding and sympathy. Dialogue provides an opportunity to share deeply held beliefs in a context of mutual respect. Dialogue and evangelism are not mutually exclusive.”

  6. What, exactly, has Palin, herself, expressed concerning her views of the Jewish religion?

    I think Republicans made a mistake by trying to suggest that Obama feels sympathetic toward Louis Farrakhan’s anti-Semitic statements.

    Is a mistake being made here in assigning a view to Palin that she, herself, hasn’t expressed?

  7. OMG, Babz, I love you! “Don’t piss on me and call it rain.”

    I needed that line! Just read that Clinton pulled out of an NYC rally because Palin got invited and is doing it, but they didn’t ask the Obama campaign to send anyone, organizers decided Clinton was big enough rep – that might be true, but for the sake of propriety, you ask the Obama campaign – ugh.

  8. Look I don’t see these folks marching their asses off to any islamic country talking this stuff. I don’t hear them trying to embrace muslims. That mess they are doing is code for “let’s shift the focus to jew hatred and see how far we get”

    That’s all I hear when I read stuff like this. I mean where is the respect and tolerance not only for jews but for themselves. If there are jews who want to get down with christianity fine…let those that want to do so seek it out. But don’t spin drama about embracing jews…calling it conversions.

    Don’t piss on me and call it rain.

  9. Babz, I really appreciate you commenting as you have because I have some folks in the blogs who try to discuss this from a theological intellectual level – remember when Ann Coulter talked about “perfecting Jews” and everyone in her camp went nuts, trying to justify it as theologically honest?

    I’m not stupid – I GET that part. But the fact is that in impact, in the way it’s carried out, and in a world of 6 billion people – with only 12 million who are Jews – this kind of talk seems crazy to me. But then, I’m a Jew, I’m not perfect.

    Sorry – I just have a very hard time with this. I want people to believe what they want to believe, but in a multicultural world, there have to be practical restraints. Not to mention a compassion for the impact of what you interpret your religion to require.

    Anyway – thanks. A lot.

  10. This is a very dangerous act. They kknow exactly what they are doing. This in my opinion is to rile up folks and start anti-semetic discussions amongst the ignorant and ill-informed.

    Timing is everything. This is not by accident. Look who the GOP has chosen as their VP candidate…it is all connected. One thing opens the door for another.


Comment here

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s