Republican Debate Winner: Michele Bachmann

It’s possible no one else will say it, but US Rep. and now Republican presidential candidate Michele Bachmann got major earned media tonight at the New Hampshire primary debate because she announced that she’s officially entering the presidential primary competition. Why else was it her night? (If you missed the debate, I live-blogged it all here and so did Joe Gandelman, here.)

She did not use any cards with graphs on them.
She did not make any sweeping generalizations about liberties, history or how much President Obama spent to do something that would fail a fact check.
She rarely evaded answers.
Her tone of voice was proper and appropriate.

And while there are other observations about her presentation that say she won this debate – or at least came out of it as the top winner, the biggest wins for her also include:

-she didn’t have the Tim Pawlenty-Rick Santorum problem of looking like someone else,
-she didn’t have the Ron Paul-Newt Gingrich I’m so mad at my mother tone of voice,
-she didn’t have the Herman Cain reliance on analogies and
-she didn’t try to look like she was the gee-whiz kid up there like Mitt Romney, staring up in awe so much of the evening when it was his turn.

Last but not least, and by far the most troublesome for Sarah Palin but also trouble for all the other candidates: she made sure that the words she used, the answers she gave related back directly to her being in office – something only Ron Paul can say also. And Bachmann is using this fact repeatedly as a verbal bludgeon to distinguish the reality that she is in a position to take action and she has and is in fact taking action on her principles, positions and beliefs.

Whoever advised her to do that is a very wise person. And I believe that as time goes by, this will be an important distinction, possibly to be undercut by critiques that she does not have “executive experience” but I’ve always thought that’s overrated anyway – unless late entrants include sitting governors like Rick Perry of Texas or Chris Christie of New Jersey.

In the meantime, I say it was Bachmann’s night – maybe not by much, given how crowded it was on that stage and during the barely two hours. But she did well, very very well.

Ha! And for confirmation, who does Chris Cillizza of The Fix has as his first winner in the winners and losers list? Yup. Me too.

More here on Bachmann triumph.

Third analysis agrees with me.  Even she who shall not be named agrees with me, of course we should ask why Bachmann was given the edge – couldn’t be because she’s a woman, just remember that.

6 thoughts on “Republican Debate Winner: Michele Bachmann

  1. Pingback: For those worried about me after positive critique of Bachmann debate performance : Writes Like She Talks

  2. Thanks very much Joanne – and I must give YOU props – I saw that you used that phrased at least once or twice recently – I stole it from you! So thank you and I’ll have to figure out a way to attribute it to you next time I use it – if I have to! 😉

    As for Bachmann, I totally am starting to build a cache of pieces related to precisely why she should not be president based on her thinking and policies. I mean, again, as with Sarah Palin, it is just so easy to argue about how wretched her ideas are. Who needs to go to all the places that the menz and media and others often do? Really – I think many voters ARE saying, “We’re so done with that – tell us something we actually don’t know.” You know?

  3. Jill, love your comment about she who shall not be named — I’ve been using that phrase, as well. 🙂 And, I find it so interesting that most of the guys — white guys — all thing the white guys one, and gave a virtual pat on the head to Bachmann. Not that I agree with her views, but I, too, believe she won the night and those others ought to be careful. She’ll sneak up on them

  4. Pingback: “Michele Bachmann Steals the Show at GOP Debate” and related posts |

  5. Pingback: In Case You Missed It – Watch the New Hampshire GOP Debate | The Lonely Conservative

Comment here

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s